Skip to main content

Blog · Litigation

Brief Filing Checklist: 40 Checks Before You File a Motion or Brief

A pre-filing checklist for litigators filing a motion, opposition, reply or appellate brief: the deadline, the judge's rules, length and the certificate of compliance, citations, tables, AI disclosure where a court requires it, signature, redaction, service and the final PDF.

A brief filing checklist covers ten things, in this order: the deadline, the judge's rules, length and the certificate of compliance, the citations, the tables, any AI disclosure the court requires, the signature block, redaction, service, and the final PDF. Most rejected or embarrassing filings fail one of these mechanical checks rather than the argument.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice. For guidance on a specific case, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.

Use the checklist below for a motion, opposition, reply or appellate brief. Federal rules are cited as the baseline, with Utah examples where state practice differs. Your court's local rules control.

1. Deadline

  • The due date is computed, not assumed. Count under FRCP 6(a) or your state's equivalent, and note whether the clock ran from filing or from service. Our guide to calculating court deadlines walks through the counting.
  • The local rule's response period is confirmed. District courts set different response and reply periods. Our table of federal motion response deadlines by district compares them.
  • Appellate dates are on the calendar. Under FRAP 31(a)(1), the appellant's brief is due 40 days after the record is filed, the appellee's 30 days after service of the appellant's brief, and a reply 21 days after service of the appellee's brief, but at least 7 days before argument unless the court allows otherwise. Circuit rules can shorten or extend these.
  • A filing-time cutoff is known. Electronic filing generally closes at midnight in the court's time zone, but check the local rule and any judge-specific earlier deadline.

2. The court's and the judge's rules

  • Local rules read for this filing type. Motions, oppositions and replies often have different limits.
  • The judge's standing order or individual practices read. Pre-motion letters, meet-and-confer certifications, courtesy copies and hearing requests usually live here. See our guide to finding a judge's standing orders.
  • Leave to file obtained, if needed. Some courts bar replies without leave. The Middle District of Florida's Local Rule 3.01 is one example.
  • Meet-and-confer certification included, if the local rule requires one for this motion.

3. Length, format and the certificate of compliance

  • Within the limit, counted the court's way. Under FRAP 32(a)(7), a principal brief is limited to 30 pages, or 13,000 words under the type-volume option, and a reply brief to 15 pages or half the type-volume limit (6,500 words). Utah's district courts cap a reply supporting a Rule 12(b), 12(c), 56 or 65A motion at 15 pages or 5,400 words under Utah R. Civ. P. 7(q).
  • Excluded items actually excluded. FRAP 32(f) leaves out the cover page, disclosure statement, tables, statement regarding oral argument, statutory addendum, certificates of counsel, signature block and proof of service. Headings, footnotes and quotations count. Local rules may define the list differently.
  • Certificate of compliance included. Under FRAP 32(g)(1), it states the word count (or the line count for monospaced type), and you may rely on the word processor's count. Utah's civil rule 7(q)(3) requires a similar certification when a filer relies on the word limit.
  • Typeface, spacing and margins match the rule. FRAP 32(a) sets the federal appellate baseline. District courts often have their own.

4. Citations

  • Every authority exists and says what the brief says. This is the step with the most at stake and the one most often rushed. Our guide to cite checking a brief sets out the full five-pass method: existence, quotes and pin cites, support at the signal, good law, and format. Run it, don't reinvent it.
  • AI-drafted passages checked line by line. If any part of the draft came from a general-purpose AI tool, every citation in that part gets the existence check, not a sample.
  • Record citations are pinpointed. Many courts require page or docket-and-page citations to the record for every factual assertion.
  • Unpublished decisions are permitted in this court, and copies are attached if the local rule requires.

This is also where your signature matters. Under FRCP 11(b)(2), signing a filing certifies that its legal contentions are warranted by existing law or a nonfrivolous argument for changing it. Our Rule 11 sanctions guide covers what that inquiry requires.

5. Tables, caption and parts

  • Table of contents and table of authorities, if required. FRAP 28(a)(2)–(3) requires both in a principal appellate brief and FRAP 28(c) in a reply; Utah's civil rule 7(o) requires both in an overlength motion or memorandum. Build them last and update them after the final edit. Our guide to creating a table of authorities has the Word steps.
  • Caption correct: court, case number, parties, judge's initials if the court uses them, and the document title.
  • Required sections present. Appellate briefs have a mandatory order under FRAP 28(a). Many trial courts require a statement of the relief sought or the issues.
  • Disclosure statement filed, if this is the party's first appearance. FRCP 7.1 and FRAP 26.1 set the federal requirements.

6. AI disclosure and certification, where required

There is no nationwide rule requiring disclosure of AI use, but a growing number of courts and judges require it. Two examples:

  • The Northern District of Texas adopted Local Civil Rule 7.2(f), effective September 3, 2024. A brief prepared using generative AI must say so on its first page under the heading "Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence." Filing a brief without the disclosure certifies that no part of it was prepared with generative AI.
  • Florida's Eleventh Judicial Circuit (Miami-Dade) requires disclosure on the face of the filing plus a certification of independent verification.

Checklist items:

  • The local rules and the judge's standing orders checked for AI provisions in this case.
  • The scope read. Does the rule cover only generative drafting, or research tools too? All filings, or only briefs?
  • The disclosure placed where the rule says, in the words it requires.
  • The certification is true. A certification that every citation was verified is a representation by the signer, not by the tool.

Our guide to whether lawyers must disclose AI use to courts maps the current orders and what a compliant certification says.

7. Signature block

  • Signed by an attorney of record, with address, email and phone, as FRCP 11(a) requires.
  • Bar number and firm name included where local rules require.
  • Pro hac vice and local counsel requirements met, if anyone on the block is not admitted.

8. Redaction and sealing

  • Personal identifiers redacted under FRCP 5.2(a): only the last four digits of a Social Security or taxpayer-identification number, the year of birth, a minor's initials, and the last four digits of a financial-account number.
  • Exhibits checked too. Bank statements, medical records and screenshots are where unredacted numbers hide.
  • Confidential material filed under seal or redacted as the protective order and local rules require, with a motion to seal if needed.
  • PDF redactions are real. Black boxes drawn over text can leave the text underneath selectable. Use a redaction tool that removes it, then test by searching the PDF.

9. Service

  • Service method known for every party. Under FRCP 5(d)(1)(B), no certificate of service is required when a paper is served by filing it with the court's electronic-filing system. FRAP 25(d) has the same exception on appeal.
  • Certificate of service included for any party served another way, such as a pro se party not on CM/ECF, stating the date, manner and persons served.
  • Courtesy copies delivered if the judge requires them.

10. The final PDF

  • The filed version is the final version. Compare the PDF against the last approved draft.
  • Tables updated after the last edit, and the hidden-text marks in Word turned off before the PDF was made.
  • Text-searchable PDF, if the court requires it, with bookmarks for long briefs where the court asks for them.
  • Exhibits attached, labeled and in order. Each exhibit referenced in the brief is actually there.
  • Proposed order attached or submitted separately if local rules require.
  • Correct event selected in CM/ECF, and the filing receipt saved to the matter file.

Frequently asked questions

What should I check before filing a brief?

Check the deadline and how it was computed, the local rules and the judge's standing order, the length limit and certificate of compliance, every citation, the tables, any AI disclosure the court requires, the signature block, redaction of personal identifiers, the certificate of service, and the final PDF. The checklist in this guide puts those in filing order.

Do I need a certificate of service if I file through CM/ECF?

Usually not in federal court. FRCP 5(d)(1)(B) says no certificate of service is required when a paper is served by filing it with the court's electronic-filing system, and FRAP 25(d) has the same exception on appeal. You still need one for anyone you serve another way, such as a party not registered for electronic filing. Check local practice.

What is a certificate of compliance?

It is a statement by counsel that a brief meets the type-volume limit. Under FRAP 32(g)(1), it must state the number of words, or lines of monospaced type, and the person preparing it may rely on the word processor's count. Many district courts and state courts require a similar certification when a filer relies on a word limit instead of a page limit.

Do I have to disclose AI use in a court filing?

Only where a court requires it, and the requirements vary. The Northern District of Texas, for example, requires a brief prepared with generative AI to say so on its first page under Local Civil Rule 7.2(f). Many individual judges have standing orders on AI. Check the court's local rules and your judge's orders for every filing.

What personal information must be redacted from a federal filing?

Under FRCP 5.2(a), a filing may include only the last four digits of a Social Security or taxpayer-identification number, the year of an individual's birth, a minor's initials, and the last four digits of a financial-account number. Exhibits count, so check attachments as carefully as the brief itself. The rule lists exemptions, and courts may order more.

Run the citation check while there is still time to fix it

Item 4 is the one that cannot wait for the last hour. If a citation fails, you need time to find a real authority or rewrite the argument. Paste the brief into CaseRead's free Hallucination Shield, or upload the file, a day before the deadline. It checks up to 50 citations per run against official statute and case-law sources, flags any it cannot verify, and needs no signup. If you want research that cites only what it retrieves from the start, see CaseRead's plans.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice. For guidance on a specific case, consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.