Yes, judges have issued orders with AI-generated errors. In July 2025, two federal district judges, Julien Xavier Neals in New Jersey and Henry T. Wingate in Mississippi, withdrew orders after lawyers pointed out invented quotations, wrong case outcomes and parties who were not in the case. Both later told the Senate Judiciary Committee that a staff member had used generative AI. State courts have also vacated orders built on lawyers' AI-drafted proposals.
The incidents matter to practitioners for two reasons. If you rely on an order, its citations need the same check as a brief's. And if you draft a proposed order, the citations in it are still yours after the judge signs it. Below is what the record shows, from the courts' and the Senate's own documents. For the far longer list of lawyer sanctions, see our AI hallucination sanctions cases.
The New Jersey securities opinion
On June 30, 2025, an opinion and order was docketed in In re CorMedix Inc. Securities Litigation, No. 2:21-cv-14020 (D.N.J.). Defense counsel wrote to the court on July 22, 2025, identifying apparent mistakes. According to the Senate Judiciary Committee's October 6, 2025 release, the decision attributed inaccurate quotes to defendants, relied on quotes attributed to decisions that did not contain them, and described motions to dismiss in other cases as denied when they had been granted. The opinion was withdrawn on July 23, 2025.
Judge Neals explained what happened in an October 20, 2025 letter to the director of the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, for transmittal to Senator Grassley. He wrote that a law school intern "used CHATGPT to perform legal research" in connection with the decision, acting without authorization, without disclosure, and contrary to chambers policy and the law school's own policy. He said the docketed document was an early draft that had not gone through the chambers' standard review, which includes cite-checking tools. His chambers' ban on generative AI in research and drafting, previously verbal, is now written. The final opinion notes in a footnote that a preliminary draft had been inadvertently issued and withdrawn.
The Mississippi DEI order
On July 20, 2025, Judge Wingate entered a temporary restraining order in Jackson Federation of Teachers v. Fitch, No. 3:25-cv-417 (S.D. Miss.), blocking enforcement of H.B. 1193, Mississippi's law restricting diversity, equity and inclusion programs in public education. Two days later the state defendants moved to clarify or correct it. The court replaced the order with a corrected version dated July 20 and declined to restore the original to the docket, calling the errors "clerical."
The Fifth Circuit later catalogued what the original contained: eleven named plaintiffs who had never been parties, two defendants who were not sued, claims about institutions cancelling programs that had no support in the record, statutory "quotations" using terms that do not appear in H.B. 1193, and references to declarations from four people who do not appear in the record.
In his October 21, 2025 letter, Judge Wingate wrote that a law clerk used Perplexity "strictly as a foundational drafting assistant to synthesize publicly available information on the docket," that no confidential information was entered, and that the docketed order was an early draft that skipped the standard review. He called the root cause "a lapse in human oversight." His chambers now require a mandatory independent review of every draft by a second law clerk, and every cited case is printed from Westlaw and attached to the final draft.
The Senate inquiry
Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley wrote to both judges on October 6, 2025. His release stated that "Article III judges should be held to a higher standard, given the binding force of their rulings." The judges' responses, and a letter from Administrative Office Director Robert J. Conrad, Jr., were released on October 23, 2025. Grassley's comment: "Honesty is always the best policy." He also called for "more decisive, meaningful and permanent AI policies and guidelines" in the judiciary.
The AO letter is the most useful document for practitioners, because it describes the federal judiciary's own rules of the road:
- An advisory AI Task Force of judges, court executives and staff, created in 2025.
- Interim guidance distributed judiciary-wide on July 31, 2025, which cautions against delegating core judicial functions such as decision-making to AI, recommends that users independently verify all AI-generated output, and asks users to consider whether AI use should be disclosed.
- A statement that the guidance is non-exhaustive and temporary while permanent policy is developed.
- An acknowledgment that the judiciary does not systematically track, at the national level, official actions involving AI-questioned filings.
The letter also noted that proposed Federal Rule of Evidence 707, on machine-generated evidence offered without an expert, was published for comment on August 15, 2025. Our post on FRE 707 covers it.
The Fifth Circuit's answer, a year later
On October 22, 2026, the Fifth Circuit decided the state's appeal from Judge Wingate's later preliminary injunction. In a published opinion by Judge Jerry E. Smith, the panel vacated the injunction and remanded for reassignment to a different district judge.
The opinion does not mince words: "The proceedings in the district court were a botch job, to say the least." It found that the corrected TRO, which the injunction incorporated by reference, still contained hallucinated material. At oral argument it emerged that the order cited "Cousins v. School Bd. of City of Norfolk," 503 F.2d 422 (4th Cir. 1974). The panel's footnote explains that the reporter page sits in the middle of an unrelated Sixth Circuit case and the pincite lands in a Second Circuit case. The court called it "an apparent AI hallucination."
The panel faulted the district court for replacing the original order without explaining why the removed "facts" had not affected its reasoning, and it rested the vacatur on legal errors as well. Reassignment, it acknowledged, is "extraordinary" and "rarely invoked." It ordered it anyway.
One more detail is worth noting. The panel wrote that it was "grateful--and, indeed, lucky" that the defendants had attached the original TRO as an exhibit to a later motion, because the district court had removed it from public view.
State courts: orders that came from counsel's drafts
The state cases look different. The AI errors entered the order through a lawyer's proposed order, and the lawyer paid for it.
- Georgia, 2025. In Shahid v. Esaam, No. A25A0196 (Ga. Ct. App. June 30, 2025), a trial court order in a divorce case, which appeared to have been prepared by the husband's attorney, cited bogus cases. The Court of Appeals vacated the order, remanded for a new hearing and imposed a $2,500 penalty on that attorney.
- Georgia, 2026. In Payne v. State, the Georgia Supreme Court in May 2026 vacated a trial court order denying a new trial in a murder case, an order largely prepared by an assistant district attorney whose briefs and proposed order contained fictitious or misattributed citations. It suspended her from practicing before that court for six months, according to Bloomberg Law, and directed that the new order not be prepared by either side's counsel.
- Oklahoma, 2026. Local reporting in September 2026 described a Stephens County judge who admitted to state investigators that a custody-case order he wrote cited at least two cases that do not exist, which he said ChatGPT supplied. The state attorney general's office said the evidence did not support criminal prosecution and noted that the Oklahoma Supreme Court has the final say on judicial discipline.
What this means for your practice
Check the order, not just the briefs. Before you quote an order in your next filing, cite it to another court or build an appeal around it, run its citations through the same check you would run on a brief. In the Mississippi case, a fabricated citation survived a "corrected" order and was found only at oral argument.
Raise errors promptly and on the record. The state defendants in Mississippi moved to clarify within two days. In New Jersey, defense counsel wrote to chambers. A narrow, factual filing that identifies each error and the correct authority is the right tone. A motion for reconsideration is a different tool with a higher bar; a motion to correct or clarify usually fits better.
Preserve the original. If a court replaces an order, make sure the version you relied on is in the record. The Fifth Circuit could review the original TRO only because the defendants had filed a copy.
Own your proposed orders. Payne and Shahid show that when a judge signs your draft, your citations become the court's errors and your discipline. Verify a proposed order with the same care as a brief, particularly in fast TRO and preliminary injunction practice, where drafts move quickly.
Do not cite withdrawn opinions. Both federal judges removed the flawed versions so no one would rely on them. Confirm which version of an order is operative before you cite it.
The common thread with Mata v. Avianca is that each problem was caught by a lawyer who opened the cited authority. That remains the only reliable check, whoever wrote the document. Our verification workflow applies to orders as well as briefs.
Frequently asked questions
Have judges used AI to write court orders with fake citations?
Yes. In 2025, U.S. District Judges Julien Xavier Neals of New Jersey and Henry T. Wingate of Mississippi withdrew orders containing errors after lawyers flagged them. Both later told Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley that a member of chambers staff had used generative AI, ChatGPT in one case and Perplexity in the other, on drafts that were docketed before normal review.
What happened to Judge Wingate's AI-tainted order on appeal?
On October 22, 2026, the Fifth Circuit vacated his preliminary injunction against Mississippi's H.B. 1193 and remanded for reassignment to a different district judge. The panel noted that even the corrected temporary restraining order, incorporated into the injunction, cited a Fourth Circuit case that does not exist. Reassignment on remand is a remedy the court called extraordinary and rarely invoked.
What did the Senate Judiciary Committee ask the judges?
On October 6, 2025, Chairman Grassley wrote to Judges Neals and Wingate about apparent AI use in their withdrawn orders. Their replies, sent through the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, were released October 23, 2025. The AO's director described an AI task force and interim guidance issued July 31, 2025, and said the judiciary does not systematically track such incidents nationally.
What should I do if a court order cites a case that does not exist?
Verify it twice from reliable sources, then raise it promptly and respectfully, usually by a motion to clarify or correct, or by letter where local practice allows. In the Mississippi case, the defendants moved to clarify and later attached the original order to a filing, which preserved it for appeal. Do not cite or rely on the order's flawed passages in the meantime.
Am I responsible for citations in a proposed order the judge signs?
In practice, yes. In Payne v. State, the Georgia Supreme Court vacated a trial court order largely prepared by a prosecutor whose citations were fictitious or misattributed, and suspended her from practicing before that court for six months. Georgia's Court of Appeals vacated a divorce-case order drafted by counsel that relied on bogus cases in Shahid v. Esaam.
Screen the order before you build on it
Paste the order you are relying on, or the proposed order you are about to submit, into the free Hallucination Shield. It checks up to 50 citations per run against official statute and case-law sources, flags anything it cannot find, and reads each source it does find against the sentence that cites it. No signup. It takes less time than a motion to clarify.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice. Matters described here may have further developments; confirm current status before relying on them.